Thursday, December 13, 2007

Muslim Subway Rider Aids Attacked Jews

This is certainly a heartwarming story. How interesting; Christians attack Jews, and the one person who comes to their rescue is a Muslim. And as I tell my kids, not everyone named "Jameel" is a terrorist :)
A suspected bias attack on four Jewish subway riders has resulted in a friendship between the Jewish victims and the Muslim college student who came to their aid.

Walter Adler is calling Hassan Askari a hero for intervening when Adler and three friends were assaulted on a subway train in lower Manhattan on Friday night.

The altercation erupted when Adler and his friends said "Happy Hanukkah" to a group yelling "Merry Christmas" on the Brooklyn-bound train.

The 20-year-old Askari said he tried to fight off the 10 attackers, giving Adler a chance to summon police by pulling an emergency brake.

"I did what I thought was right," said Askari, a student at Berkeley College in Manhattan, who was allegedly punched and beaten. "I did the best that I could to help."

Eight men and two women have pleaded not guilty to assault, menacing and other charges in the case. Prosecutors have said the charges could be upgraded to hate crimes.

"That a random Muslim kid helped some Jewish kids, that's what's positive about New York," said Adler, 23, who suffered a broken nose and a lip wound.

The Anti Defamation League applauded the New York City Police Wednesday for the arrests of 10 individuals suspected in the "vicious, unprovoked, and prolonged" anti-Semitic attack on the students.

'We were shocked and saddened to hear of the vicious, unprovoked and prolonged anti-Semitic attack perpetrated against four Jewish students celebrating Hanukkah.

"We applaud the speed and efficiency of the NYPD and its Hate Crimes Task Force in treating this bias incident seriously, and look forward to seeing the perpetrators prosecuted to the fullest extent of the law," the grouo said in a statement.

"We recognize the courage of the fellow subway rider who attempted to defend the victims from their attackers. It is heartening that there are good people who are willing to stand up when they witness racism, prejudice or bigotry," ADL concluded.


Maybe I should bring this guy as backup next time I go to Kever Yosef.

Wherever I am, my blog turns towards Eretz Yisrael

19 comments:

therapydoc said...

Some back up would be good. As those of us who support say in Chicago, Husain (sp?) is a good name, or should be, someone who brings peace.

J. said...

Adler, 23, who suffered a broken nose and a lip wound.

Kids? They should grow up and fight back.

mevaseretzion said...

um...4 against 10? It sounds like they were fighting back.

LakewoodShmuck said...

good post

Anonymous said...

You know, there was a brouhaha in America earlier this year because people kept calling Senator Barak Obama "eloquent". It sounds innocent enough, but the problem was that all these politically correct white people were making this observation because they didn't expect the average African American to be able to speak eloquently or form ideas with any great skill. It may sound silly, but if you think about it, it rings true. True equality dictates that it should come as no surprise that he is eloquent. He's just a person, just like the rest of us.
The same applies to this post. To me, it comes as no surprise that a Muslim helped a group of Jews in physical danger. It's definitely laudable, and worthy of praise, but it wasn't that important to him who the victims were. Jews and Muslims were not natural enemies to this man. I would like to think I would help a Muslim in distress as well.
What makes the post so striking is that you feel the need to single out this person as exceptional. Why wouldn't he help them? I guess it's just easier to think that the average, nonexceptional Muslim considers all Jews unworthy of aid.
It's so easy to interchange the words Muslim and terrorist on a regular basis. I guess I should find this post heartening, and yet...

Jameel @ The Muqata said...

Anonymous: In my neck of the woods, the bullets, motolv coktails and rocks only fly in one direction; from Muslims....against civilian Jews.

It's not simple educating children that not ALL Muslims are evil terrorists...when they happen to be the #1 terrorists trying to kill us.

Jack's Shack said...

It is a nice story. Too bad we don't read about this kind of stuff more often.

Anonymous said...

Jameel,
Actually Israel is filled with peace loving Muslims. The city of Shchem which you drove through the other daY IS NOT A CITY OF ALL TERRORISTS. tHERE ARE BUTCHERS, BAKERS, RUG MAKERS, ET AL.By any accounting, the terrorists of which you speak are a small minority of the population. And what of Israeli Arabs who do not live in the West bank? They too are not hostile, as a rule, unless of course you think otherwise.
mY POINT IS THAT YOUR POST SUGGESTS THAT PEACEFYUL mUSLIMS ARE THE EXCEPTION. aCTUALLY, THEY ARE THE VAST MAJORITY. You just don't know any. You probably don't personally know any Muslims at all. aND EVEN IF THEY WEREN'T, IT'S SO SAD THAT YOU FEEL THE NEED TO SINGLE ONE OUT LIKE HIS ACTION WAS EXCEPTIONAL BECAUSE HE WAS mUSLIM. His behavior is admirable, as it would be of any person.
jUST ONE MAN'S OPINION.....

Anonymous said...

Sounds like a nice guy--glad he was in the right place at the right time.
Says tha Balabusta in Blue Jeans:

I'm less interested in the fact that the Good Samaritan was Muslim, actually (Jameel, see your point, but here in the utmost West, the lines are much more blurry and meandering), than in the fact that apparently yelling "Happy Hanukkah" will get you attacked on a subway car in Manhattan. We have got some ways to go...

Bubba said...

I am offended that you call these people Christians just because they said, "Merry Christmas." They were no more Christians than they were Jews or Muslims or Hindus. They are foolish, unloving, bigoted individuals.

True Christians that I know would lay down their lives for your nation. We fully believe you have every right to be there and rejoice that G-d is drawing you back to the land.

I hope you don't view every person in America who is not Jewish (or Muslim) as a Christian. It just isn't true. Please don't attack those in this world who deeply care for you and your people.

almnigj said...

Don't Israeli citizens drive by peaceful members of Islam every day? Doesn't the country have over a million Israeli Arabs? I'm not an expert on Israel, but I can't imagine they're all terrorists. Maybe if you need to teach your kids that not all members of Islam are terrorists, drive a few miles and show them an Arab village. There are many peaceful villages all over Israel, some less than one hundred yards from Jewish kibbutzim and cities. I think that might be a better education for your Sabra children than an article about the subway in NYC. Maybe it would be a good education for you, too. Signed, a liberally minded nonIsraeli galut Jew

Lurker said...

Bubba: I am offended that you call these people Christians just because they said, "Merry Christmas." They were no more Christians than they were Jews or Muslims or Hindus. They are foolish, unloving, bigoted individuals.

Are you also offended when people call the Crusaders Christians? How about the Torquemada and the rest of the Inquisitors? Are you offended when people call Martin Luther a Christian? If so, then you are offended by close to 100% of all European and Christian history books.

All the people an groups I mentioned above were "foolish, unloving, bigoted individuals". (Martin Luther, founder of Protestantism, was arguably the worst.) They were also, obviously, Christians.

Btw -- people in the U.S. (of all creeds and colors) get offended much too easily these days. Chill out a bit.

Bubba: True Christians that I know would lay down their lives for your nation. We fully believe you have every right to be there and rejoice that G-d is drawing you back to the land.

Your support is appreciated. Very much so, in fact. But please don't be so blind as to recognize that, as supporters of Israel, you are unfortuately a minority among Christians worldwide. Here are some typical examples:

Presbyterians' Shameful Boycott

The Episcopal Church's Anti-Israel Media Campaign

World Council of Churches slams Israel

Evangelicals' letter backs PA state

Bubba: I hope you don't view every person in America who is not Jewish (or Muslim) as a Christian. It just isn't true. Please don't attack those in this world who deeply care for you and your people.

The point of Jameel's post was not to attack Christians, and certainly not to attack anyone who cares for us, such as yourself. The point was to applaud a good, decent, and courageous young man, who happened to be a Muslim.

Lurker said...

"But please don't be so blind as to recognize" should be "so blind as to fail to recognize".

Karl Newman said...

Jameel,

What makes you think the attackers were Christians? Because they were shouting Merry Christmas?

Lurker,

Bubba is right. Those people were not Christians. You need to learn the difference between those who call themselves Christians and the real thing.

True, Luther was an anti-Semite bigot. There are observant Jewish bigots out there, too. Just read the comments section in the Jerusalem Post anytime Evangelicals are mentioned in an article. You won't find a group of any size that doesn't have a lunatic fringe. As for the Crusaders, they were wolves in sheep's clothing. What they did to the Jews was in direct violation of the teaching of Jesus and his disciples. Once Christianity became the official faith of the Roman Empire, the corruption of Rome set in and became progressively worse throughout the ages. Heck, Luther was a reformer.

As for the links you posted, those denominations and groups are heretical, led by 'clergy' that are often unreformed '60s flower children. One branch of the Presbyterian Church even hosted a women's conference back in the mid-90s that consisted of pagan goddess worship and was attended by women from all the mainline Protestant denominations. There is no way those people are true Christians. They don't believe in the tenets of the faith. Judaism has the same problem, BTW.

And yet, there has always been at least a remnant of true believers. That remnant, the real Christians, were often persecuted by the visible church, just like the Jews. We're still around and we don't beat up Jews. What we do is use our political muscle to keep the US from abandoning Israel, among other things. We're not your enemy.

Miriam said...

I Long for the day with Muslims and Jews unite....

Elchonon said...

Anoyn & Almnigj,
Are you nuts ? the only reason they dont kill us half the time is because #1 we are armed and #2 trhe army is around.

Maybe the whole population is not engaged full time in wholesale murder.. Sorry but if they themselfs dont do it it's because they lack the cojones.

Most arabs here are supportive or at least agreeable to the terror, and if they disagree its purely for the fact that they believe it hurts their cause and day to day life.

Even if you can prove that 90% of my arab neighbers love me, I still am not going near em, there are 10% then that are out to kill me and I dont know who..

I have had 14 operations, getting cut while sleeping is painfyull enough.. i'll pass on getting stabbed.

kach613 said...

I have had it! I dont have to look for the so calld good baker that wont kill me.They have to prove it to us,when was the last time a Jew took a plane and smashed into a bulding in the name of G-d. I have had it with you libs. This is a great story and great job by Jameel,the so calld good ones have to show us that they are I dont have to find them!

Anonymous said...

kach 613 and elchonon,
I rest so much easier at nt knowing that you folks are the ones with guns

Elchonon said...

Anonymus,
You should, I can handle a handgun damn well..

Search the Muqata

Loading...

LinkWithin

Related Posts with Thumbnails